| Base Ball, Pinnacle, 1996, Don Mattingly, #99, mint |
| Baseball Card Pacific 1996 Don Mattingly #DC 4 Insert |
| 1996 Don Mattingly Starting Lineup SLU New York Yankees |
| 1996 SLU EXT MLB Don Mattingly NY Yankees rare w/bonus! |
| 1996 TSC Extreme Players Gold Don Mattingly ! Yankees |
| 1996 Don Mattingly Retirement Yankees Burger King Ball |
| 1996 Don Mattingly Starting Lineup SLU New York Yankees |
| 1996 FLEER #189 DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 *123 |
| 1996 SCORE #8 DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 *542 |
| 1996 PINNACLE STARBURST DON MATTINGLY CARD # 37 ~ MINT |
| 1996 SPORTFLIX PRO MOTION DON MATTINGLY ~ MINT~YANKEES |
| 1996 PACIFIC DON MATTINGLY MILESTONE #M-2 |
| 1996 PANINI STICKER DON MATTINGLY # 151 ~ MINT~YANKEES |
| 1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Don Mattingly Yankees Great |
| 1996 Score Numbers Game Yankees DON MATTINGLY |
| 1996 Score Dugout Collection DON MATTINGLY Yankees |
| 1996 Pacific Don Mattingly HP-5 |
| 1996 TOPPS PROFILES PLUS REGULAR CARD DON MATTINGLY |
| 3 DIFFERENT 1996 PINNACLE DON MATTINGLY CARDS ~ MINT |
| 1996 TOPPS DON MATTINGLY PROFILES INSERT #AL-17 YANKEES |
| 1996 PACIFIC DON MATTINGLY DIE CUT DC-4 |
| 1996 SPORTFLIX PRO MOTION DON MATTINGLY 12 OF 20 |
| 1996 Fleer Ultra Gold Medallion Don Mattingly |
| 1996 Score Dugout #8 Don Mattingly Yankees |
| 1996 PINNACLE DON MATTINGLY STARBURST 84 OF 100 |
| Beckett baseball June 1996 David Justice/Don Mattingly |